The pain of purchasing the wrong item is not describable. This article saves you the opportunity to choose wisely depending on the task at hand the saw of your choice. We understand that you might be in a dilemma as to what to buy. It is why this article has been written up for you.
If you’re planning on purchasing a saw, but you’re not sure which you want to buy. Between the scroll saw vs band saw, you’ve come to the right place. We’ll be enlightening you on the uses and advantages of the two saws.
Table of Contents
- Section 1: When do we need a Scroll Saw?
- Section 2: When do we need band saw?
- Section 3: In These Cases, Will Abandon Scroll Saw VS Band Saw
- Section 4: Similarities And Differences Of The Scroll Saw VS Band Saw
- Section 5: Public Testimonials About The Two Saws
- Section 6: Can The Two Saws Be Used Together?
Section 1: When do we need a Scroll Saw?
What is a scroll saw first of all? A scroll saw is an electric saw or a pedal-operated saw, wood/metal operators use it to make complex curves in wood, metal, or other materials. The size range could be as small as 10-12 inches to about 30 inches for the industrial user. The magnitude of the work you want to do determines the throat size you should buy.
You should use a scroll saw when you want to cut intricate curves and joints during your woodwork. The purpose of designing these is for them, and they perform the tasks quickly and accurately. They are also useful in making dovetail joints in woods and are known commonly helpful when working on thicker intarsia jobs. Over the band saw, the scroll saw has the advantage of cutting extremely tight curves and making pierce cuts.
Overall, the scroll saw should be your choice when you are working with small materials of little thickness like in wooden letters or plaques.
Section 2: When do we need band saw?
The band saw is a power saw that is used principally in wood- and metal-working and lumbering. They are advantageous over the scroll saw in that they are more capable of cutting uniformly and in many intricate shapes. Band saws can be small or medium-sized, large (double cut, re-saws and head saws) and are usually vertical, that is, have to be mounted on a flat surface, like a bench. The cutting saw blade here is kept fixed. And the workplace moved around the blade, making it a better choice for cutting shapes and edges.
The other option is to purchase the flat design that holds the workplace while it swings around it. This design/configuration is not utilizable in cutting edges and shapes but useful in long cuts as in pipes. The band saw has had several improvements to better adapt them to either woodworking (usually lighter ,and less complex) or metalworking.
The latter incorporating a welder, coolant or power feed mechanisms, and recently, double metal blades/bimetal blades.
Section 3: In These Cases, Will Abandon Scroll Saw VS Band Saw
The scroll saw should not be your choice if you’d be working on wood thicker than about 1 inch. And when you are be making straight cuts through a material. When you’re looking to make straight rip cuts also, the scroll saw should not cross your mind. It is because they have features which makes them useful for only curves and kind of useless for straight lines.
You shouldn’t use a band saw for making inside cuts and when you are or will be too lazy to get more sanding done. Considering how rough the edges of a band-sawed material turns out. The speed and aggressiveness of the band saw makes it useful for rip cuts and thicker materials than the scroll saw can handle. The band saw should not be put into consideration when making inside reductions too. It would damage the final looks and integrity of the wood.
Section 4: Similarities And Differences Of The Scroll Saw VS Band Saw
Apart from the fact that the band and scroll saws are both power saws that are used to make cuts in objects, there are not many similarities between them, and even though they might look alike, they have incredibly different peculiarities and functions.
While a scroll saw uses a short blade that moves up and down, the band saw runs on two, and sometimes up to four wheels with circular and very flexible blades. There’s no argument that the band saw is more potent than the scroll saw in that it also cuts through metals. The band saw can also cut through any thickness of material just as long as you can fit the workpiece on it. The band saw is also more suitable for making long rip cuts. The band saw is also a versatile tool.
There’s no doubt that the band saw has more advantages over the scroll saw but with a band saw, you can make plunge cuts. It is not possible with a group saw.
Section 5: Public Testimonials About The Two Saws
Here are some public reviews about the scroll saw:
I saw me a few days ago. I made a lot of wooden crafts, so I want to try this. I usually use a full size rolling saw, so my expectations are a bit high. It is not disappointing. It handles 3/4 “better than my big saw. It will cut 1 1/2”, but you have to slow down a bit. You won’t be slower than a bigger saw. I spent more than five hours in the studio today, most of the time using the Dremel reel saw. – Tim (2015)
I am very impressed so far. It is my first time using this saw, so I watched some YouTube videos on this topic to help me understand some tips. Got a reward! Because I know what happens,I can quickly apply what I have learned and be able to complete my first project successfully. I know more practice; I will become a professional! – Amazon customer, 2013
Suitable for light woodworkers. Good quality. I use it to make spruce and other wood up to 1/4 inch. I did use it for some oak barrels and saw it slow down a bit, but it still did the job. Motor speed control is excellent. I also got it with the foot pedal, which allowed me to hold the workpiece with both hands while starting and stopping the saw. Overall, I am delighted. – Christian (2016)
Here are some about the band saw:
This saw can cut metal pipes, brackets, etc. Unlike a tortuous reciprocating saw, this is simple and fast. I have nothing to make me complain. – Horse Short (2018)
If you don’t like to use a hacksaw, then this is your tool. I built an audio cabinet for the sound system of my music group and had to use a considerable amount of threaded steel rods to adjust the side dimensions, all of which were trimmed to correct the length. The idea of handling dozens of cuts through the threaded rod (leaving the rod end to accept the nut) did not satisfy me. – Stibal (2017)
Section 6: Can The Two Saws Be Used Together?
Are you considering getting both saws and wondering if they can or cannot work together? The scroll saw and the band saw might look similar when looked at considering they both feature a work table and table, after this, they are not interchangeable.
Well, there are cases where you may need both. With a scroll saw. You can’t make straight rip cuts in thick woods. Also with just a band saw, you can’t cut out super tight curves. With this said, it is better to have both saws, but if you’re facing financial constraint. It’s advisable you get the one whose capabilities suits you most.
Conclusively, when working on a variety of projects, having both scroll saw and band saw in your possession is justifiable. Since they are both different tools with different capabilities, you’ll surely find a way to use both
In summary, before purchasing just any of the two saws, you should consider your pocket and the kind of work you want to do. As said earlier, the scroll saw has more significance when working on much smaller pieces of wood. When you are into beautiful work and works that require fine, intricate cuts and details. The band saw handles more complex actions, larger pieces of wood and even metals. It is also generally more expensive than the scroll saw.